e.l.f. Cosmetics Liquid Poreless Putty Primer vs TATCHA The Silk Canvas Filter Finish Protective Primer

Both TATCHA The Silk Canvas Filter Finish Protective Primer and e.l.f. Cosmetics Liquid Poreless Putty Primer aim to create a smooth base for makeup, but they differ in formulation and price point. TATCHA's primer is enriched with unique ingredients like Saccharomyces/Rice Ferment Filtrate and Hydrolyzed Silk, which contribute to its luxurious feel and performance. In contrast, e.l.f. Cosmetics offers a more straightforward formula that still includes key ingredients like Dimethicone and Glycerin for hydration and a soft-focus effect. While TATCHA's product may appeal to those seeking a high-end experience, e.l.f. Cosmetics provides a budget-friendly option that delivers similar results. The choice between the two ultimately depends on personal preference for ingredient composition and price sensitivity.

Match
85%
Price
$10.00
Category
Makeup
Type
Face Primer
Ingredients
30 ingredients
Buy
Match
85%
Price
$55.00
Category
Makeup
Type
Face Primer
Ingredients
41 ingredients
Buy

What's inside

What's inside

Key ingredients

Key ingredients

Benefits

Benefits

Concerns

Concerns

Ingredients Side-by-side

  1. WaterSolvent
  2. DimethiconeAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Skin Protectant, Emollient, Skin Protectant
  3. HDI / TRIMETHYLOL HEXYLLACTONE CROSSPOLYMERAnti-Caking
  4. TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATEAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner
  5. GlycerinDenaturant, Hair Conditioner, Humectant, Oral Care, Skin Protectant, Solvent, Viscosity Controller, Perfuming Agent, Fragrance, Humectant Skin Conditioner
  6. C9-12 ALKANESolvent
  7. PolymethylsilsesquioxaneOpacifying Agent, Texture Enhancer
  8. CETYL PEG / PPG-10 / 1 DIMETHICONEEmulsifying Surfactant, Skin Conditioner, Cleansing Surfactant
+22 more ingredients
  1. Propylene GlycolHumectant, Fragrance, Solvent, Viscosity Controller, Humectant Skin Conditioner, Other Skin Conditioner
  2. HYDROGENATED POLYISOBUTENEEmollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Viscosity Controller
  3. DIMETHICONE / VINYL DIMETHICONE CROSSPOLYMERSkin Conditioner, Viscosity Controller
  4. SODIUM CHLORIDEBulking Agent, Fragrance, Oral Care, Viscosity Controller
  5. POLYGLYCERYL-4 ISOSTEARATEEmulsifying Surfactant
  6. PhenoxyethanolAntimicrobial, Preservative
  7. DISTEARDIMONIUM HECTORITELight Stabilizer, Viscosity Controller
  8. SilicaAbrasive, Absorbent, Anti-Caking, Bulking Agent, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller, Texture Enhancer
  9. PROPYLENE CARBONATESolvent, Viscosity Controller
  10. EthylhexylglycerinDeodorant, Skin Conditioner, Preservative
  11. Caprylyl GlycolDeodorant, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Hair Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Preservative, Humectant
  12. Disodium EDTAChelating Agent, Viscosity Controller, Chelating Agent, Stabilizer
  13. TRIETHOXYCAPRYLYLSILANEBinding Agent
  14. SqualaneEmollient Skin Conditioner, Hair Conditioner, Refatting Agent, Skin Conditioner, Emollient
  15. Butylene GlycolHumectant, Fragrance, Skin Conditioner, Solvent, Viscosity Controller
  16. HYDROXYPROPYL CYCLODEXTRINFragrance, Skin Conditioner
  17. CYCLODEXTRINAbsorbent, Chelating Agent
  18. POLYDEXTROSEBulking Agent, Humectant
  19. RESVERATROLAntioxidant, Skin Protectant
  20. TocopherolAntioxidant, Fragrance, Other Skin Conditioner, Occlusive Skin Conditioner
  21. CI 77491Colorant
  22. CI 77492Colorant

Ingredients Side-by-side

  1. DimethiconeAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Skin Protectant, Emollient, Skin Protectant
  2. WaterSolvent
  3. GlycerinDenaturant, Hair Conditioner, Humectant, Oral Care, Skin Protectant, Solvent, Viscosity Controller, Perfuming Agent, Fragrance, Humectant Skin Conditioner
  4. SACCHAROMYCES / RICE FERMENT FILTRATESkin Conditioner
  5. HDI / TRIMETHYLOL HEXYLLACTONE CROSSPOLYMERAnti-Caking
  6. PropanediolSolvent, Viscosity Controller, Humectant
  7. CERESINAntistatic, Binding Agent, Emulsion Stabilizer, Hair Conditioner, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller
  8. SqualaneEmollient Skin Conditioner, Hair Conditioner, Refatting Agent, Skin Conditioner, Emollient
+33 more ingredients
  1. DIMETHICONE / PEG-10 / 15 CROSSPOLYMERFilm Former, Opacifying Agent
  2. FragranceFragrance
  3. CAESALPINIA SPINOSA FRUIT EXTRACTSkin Protectant
  4. CAMELLIA SINENSIS LEAF EXTRACTAntimicrobial, Antioxidant, Astringent, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Humectant, Fragrance, Oral Care, Skin Conditioner, Skin Protectant, Tonic, UV Absorber
  5. CLADOSIPHON OKAMURANUS EXTRACTSkin Conditioner
  6. KAPPAPHYCUS ALVAREZII EXTRACTSkin Conditioner
  7. HYDROLYZED SILKAntistatic, Hair Conditioner, Humectant, Skin Conditioner
  8. SERICINAntistatic, Hair Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Smoothing Agent
  9. TocopherolAntioxidant, Fragrance, Other Skin Conditioner, Occlusive Skin Conditioner
  10. BIOSACCHARIDE GUM-4Skin Conditioner
  11. PEG / PPG-18 / 18 DIMETHICONEEmulsifying Surfactant
  12. DIMETHICONE / VINYL DIMETHICONE CROSSPOLYMERSkin Conditioner, Viscosity Controller
  13. PEG-9 POLYDIMETHYLSILOXYETHYL DIMETHICONEEmulsifying Surfactant, Skin Conditioner
  14. POLYGLYCERYL-2 DIISOSTEARATEEmulsifying Surfactant
  15. DISTEARYLDIMONIUM CHLORIDEAntistatic, Hair Conditioner
  16. TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATEAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner
  17. SilicaAbrasive, Absorbent, Anti-Caking, Bulking Agent, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller, Texture Enhancer
  18. ZINC STEARATEAnti-Caking, Colorant, Viscosity Controller, Slip Modifier
  19. YEAST EXTRACTSkin Conditioner, Skin Protectant
  20. ALUMINUM HYDROXIDEEmollient Skin Conditioner, Humectant, Opacifying Agent, Skin Protectant, Viscosity Controller
  21. EthylhexylglycerinDeodorant, Skin Conditioner, Preservative
  22. DIPROPYLENE GLYCOLFragrance, Solvent, Viscosity Controller, Perfuming Agent
  23. 1,2-HEXANEDIOLSkin Conditioner, Solvent
  24. Caprylyl GlycolDeodorant, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Hair Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Preservative, Humectant
  25. SODIUM CITRATEBuffering Agent, Chelating Agent, Fragrance
  26. STEARIC ACIDCleansing Agent, Emulsifying Surfactant, Emulsion Stabilizer, Fragrance, Refatting Agent, Cleansing Surfactant
  27. PhenoxyethanolAntimicrobial, Preservative
  28. ISOPROPYL ALCOHOLAntifoaming, Solvent, Viscosity Controller, Perfuming Agent
  29. LimoneneDeodorant, Solvent, Perfuming Agent, Fragrance Allergen
  30. LINALOOLDeodorant, Perfuming Agent
  31. CITRALFragrance, Perfuming Agent, Flavoring Agent
  32. CI 77891Colorant
  33. CI 77491Colorant

Ingredients Explained

Water

Solvent · Shared

Aqua, commonly known as water, serves primarily as a solvent in cosmetic formulations. It is the most abundant ingredient in many products and is essential for dissolving other ingredients, facilitating their application and absorption on the skin. Formulators often add Aqua to create a suitable texture and consistency, ensuring that products are easy to spread and apply. Additionally, water can help to hydrate the skin, making it a vital component in many moisturizing formulations.

Dimethicone

Antifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Skin Protectant, Emollient, Skin Protectant · Shared

Dimethicone is a silicone-based polymer commonly used in cosmetics for its emollient properties. It forms a protective barrier on the skin, which helps to lock in moisture and provides a smooth, silky feel. This ingredient is often added to formulations to enhance the texture and spreadability of products, making them easier to apply. Additionally, Dimethicone acts as a skin-protectant, helping to shield the skin from environmental stressors and contributing to a more refined appearance.

HDI / TRIMETHYLOL HEXYLLACTONE CROSSPOLYMER

Anti-Caking · Shared

HDI/TRIMETHYLOL HEXYLLACTONE CROSSPOLYMER has the function label of anticaking. These recorded roles explain why a formulator may include it in a cosmetic formula.

TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATE

Antifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner · Shared

TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATE is a silicone-based compound commonly used in cosmetics for its multifunctional properties. It serves primarily as an antifoaming agent, helping to reduce foam formation during the manufacturing process and application of products. Additionally, it acts as a skin-conditioning emollient, providing a smooth and soft feel to the skin, while also enhancing the overall texture of formulations. Formulators may add TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATE to improve product performance, stability, and sensory attributes, making it a valuable ingredient in various cosmetic applications.

Glycerin

Denaturant, Hair Conditioner, Humectant, Oral Care, Skin Protectant, Solvent, Viscosity Controller, Perfuming Agent, Fragrance, Humectant Skin Conditioner · Shared

Glycerin, also known as Glycerine, is a naturally occurring compound that serves primarily as a humectant in cosmetic formulations. This means it has the ability to attract moisture from the environment and bind it to the skin, helping to maintain hydration levels. Due to its effective moisturizing properties, formulators often include Glycerin in products to enhance skin softness and elasticity, making it a popular choice in various skincare and cosmetic formulations.

DIMETHICONE / VINYL DIMETHICONE CROSSPOLYMER

Skin Conditioner, Viscosity Controller · Shared

DIMETHICONE/VINYL DIMETHICONE CROSSPOLYMER is a silicone-based ingredient commonly used in cosmetics for its skin-conditioning and viscosity-controlling properties. It helps to create a smooth, silky texture in formulations, enhancing the overall feel of the product on the skin. This ingredient can also improve the spreadability of formulations, making them easier to apply and more pleasant to use. Formulators may add DIMETHICONE/VINYL DIMETHICONE CROSSPOLYMER to achieve a desired consistency and to provide a protective barrier on the skin, which can help to retain moisture. Its ability to modify the texture of products makes it a valuable component in various cosmetic applications.

Phenoxyethanol

Antimicrobial, Preservative · Shared

Phenoxyethanol is a widely used cosmetic ingredient recognized for its role as a preservative. It helps to prevent the growth of bacteria, mold, and yeast in cosmetic formulations, thereby extending the shelf life of products and ensuring their safety for consumers. Formulators may add Phenoxyethanol to protect the integrity of the product and maintain its effectiveness over time, especially in water-based formulations where microbial growth is a concern.

Silica

Abrasive, Absorbent, Anti-Caking, Bulking Agent, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller, Texture Enhancer · Shared

Silica, known by its INCI name 'Silica', is a naturally occurring mineral that is commonly used in cosmetic formulations. It serves primarily as an absorbent, helping to control oil and moisture levels in products, which can enhance the overall feel and finish on the skin. Additionally, Silica acts as a texture-enhancer, contributing to a smoother application and improving the sensory experience of the product. Formulators may add Silica to achieve a lightweight, non-greasy feel while also providing a matte finish, making it a versatile ingredient in various cosmetic applications.