JudyDoll Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner vs Urban Decay Cosmetics 24/7 Inks Easy Ergonomic Liquid Eyeliner Pen

Both the Urban Decay Cosmetics 24/7 Inks Easy Ergonomic Liquid Eyeliner Pen and the JudyDoll Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner offer precision and a smooth application experience, appealing to those who prioritize detail in their eye makeup. The Urban Decay version is ergonomically designed for comfort, while JudyDoll focuses on delivering ultra-fine lines. Ingredient-wise, they share a significant number of common components, which enhances their performance and texture. However, there are notable differences, including the presence of unique ingredients in each formula and varying risk flags associated with their use. The JudyDoll eyeliner is positioned as a more budget-friendly option, which may attract users looking for effective yet economical choices.

Match
80%
Price
$11.99
Category
Makeup
Type
Eyeliner
Ingredients
21 ingredients
Buy
Match
80%
Price
$28.00
Category
Makeup
Type
Eyeliner
Ingredients
24 ingredients
Buy

What's inside

What's inside

Key ingredients

Key ingredients

Benefits

Benefits

Concerns

Concerns

Ingredients Side-by-side

  1. WaterSolvent
  2. CI 77491Colorant
  3. ACRYLATES / ETHYLHEXYL ACRYLATE COPOLYMERFilm Former
  4. Butylene GlycolHumectant, Fragrance, Skin Conditioner, Solvent, Viscosity Controller
  5. 1,2-HEXANEDIOLSkin Conditioner, Solvent
  6. PhenoxyethanolAntimicrobial, Preservative
  7. TITANIUM / TITANIUM DIOXIDEColorant, Opacifying Agent
  8. BEHENETH-30Cleansing Agent, Emulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
+16 more ingredients
  1. HYDROXYACETOPHENONEAntioxidant
  2. AMMONIUM ACRYLATES COPOLYMERAntistatic, Binding Agent, Film Former, Viscosity Controller
  3. Caprylyl GlycolDeodorant, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Hair Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Preservative, Humectant
  4. SODIUM DEHYDROACETATEPreservative
  5. AMINOMETHYL PROPANOLBuffering Agent
  6. POLYGLYCERYL-3 DISILOXANE DIMETHICONEHair Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Cleansing Surfactant
  7. Citric AcidBuffering Agent, Chelating Agent, Fragrance, Exfoliant, Active Ingredient, pH Adjuster
  8. MICROCRYSTALLINE CELLULOSEAbrasive, Absorbent, Anti-Caking, Bulking Agent, Emulsion Stabilizer, Opacifying Agent, Light Stabilizer, Viscosity Controller
  9. SORBITAN TRIOLEATEEmulsifying Surfactant
  10. PEG-40 STEARATEEmulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
  11. PEG-60 HYDROGENATED CASTOR OILEmulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
  12. Xanthan GumBinding Agent, Emulsifying Surfactant, Emulsion Stabilizer, Gel Former, Skin Conditioner, Cleansing Surfactant, Viscosity Controller, Thickener
  13. POLYGLYCERYL-10 MYRISTATESkin Conditioner
  14. POLYGLYCERYL-10 STEARATESkin Conditioner
  15. CELLULOSE GUMBinding Agent, Emulsion Stabilizer, Film Former, Fragrance, Viscosity Controller
  16. TocopherolAntioxidant, Fragrance, Other Skin Conditioner, Occlusive Skin Conditioner

Ingredients Explained

Water

Solvent · Shared

Aqua, commonly known as water, serves primarily as a solvent in cosmetic formulations. It is the most abundant ingredient in many products and is essential for dissolving other ingredients, facilitating their application and absorption on the skin. Formulators often add Aqua to create a suitable texture and consistency, ensuring that products are easy to spread and apply. Additionally, water can help to hydrate the skin, making it a vital component in many moisturizing formulations.

Butylene Glycol

Humectant, Fragrance, Skin Conditioner, Solvent, Viscosity Controller · Shared

Butylene Glycol is a versatile ingredient commonly used in cosmetic formulations as a solvent and humectant. As a solvent, it helps to dissolve other ingredients, ensuring a uniform distribution and enhancing the overall texture of the product. Its humectant properties allow it to attract moisture from the environment into the skin, contributing to hydration and improving the skin's moisture retention. Formulators may add Butylene Glycol to enhance the sensory experience of a product, improve its stability, and boost the efficacy of other active ingredients.

1,2-HEXANEDIOL

Skin Conditioner, Solvent · Shared

1,2-HEXANEDIOL is a synthetic diol that serves primarily as a skin-conditioning agent and solvent in cosmetic formulations. Its skin-conditioning properties help to improve the feel and texture of products on the skin, making them more pleasant to use. Additionally, as a solvent, it aids in dissolving other ingredients, ensuring a uniform and stable formulation. Formulators may choose to include 1,2-HEXANEDIOL for its ability to enhance product performance and sensory attributes, contributing to an overall improved user experience.

Phenoxyethanol

Antimicrobial, Preservative · Shared

Phenoxyethanol is a widely used cosmetic ingredient recognized for its role as a preservative. It helps to prevent the growth of bacteria, mold, and yeast in cosmetic formulations, thereby extending the shelf life of products and ensuring their safety for consumers. Formulators may add Phenoxyethanol to protect the integrity of the product and maintain its effectiveness over time, especially in water-based formulations where microbial growth is a concern.

AMINOMETHYL PROPANOL

Buffering Agent · Shared

AMINOMETHYL PROPANOL is a multifunctional ingredient commonly used in cosmetic formulations primarily for its buffering properties. It helps to maintain the pH balance of products, ensuring that they remain stable and effective over time. This is particularly important in formulations that contain active ingredients sensitive to pH changes. By providing a controlled environment, AMINOMETHYL PROPANOL enhances the overall performance and safety of cosmetic products, making it a valuable addition for formulators aiming for optimal product efficacy.