L'Oréal Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner vs Benefit Cosmetics Roller Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
In comparing the L'Oréal Infallible Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner with the Benefit Cosmetics Roller Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, both products emphasize precision and long-lasting wear. The L'Oréal eyeliner features a similar base of ingredients, with notable overlaps that suggest comparable performance. However, the Benefit liner includes additional components that may contribute to a different application experience. Both products are designed to be hydrating and share a potential irritant label, which is important for users with sensitive skin. While the L'Oréal option may appeal to those looking for a slim applicator and a slightly different formulation, the Benefit liner remains a strong choice for its established reputation in the market. Ultimately, the decision may come down to personal preference regarding application style and brand loyalty.
- Match
- 80%
- Price
- $10.99
- Category
- Makeup
- Type
- Eyeliner
- Ingredients
- 21 ingredients
- Match
- 80%
- Price
- $26.00
- Category
- Makeup
- Type
- Eyeliner
- Ingredients
- 23 ingredients
What's inside
What's inside
Key ingredients
No key ingredient signals are available in this snapshot.
Key ingredients
No key ingredient signals are available in this snapshot.
Benefits
Benefits
No benefit signals are available in this snapshot.
Concerns
Concerns
Ingredients Side-by-side
- WaterSolvent
- STYRENE / ACRYLATES / AMMONIUM METHACRYLATE COPOLYMERFilm Former, Opacifying Agent
- METHYLPROPANEDIOLSolvent
- PPG-70 TOCOPHERETH-100Anti-Caking, Antioxidant, Skin Conditioner
- POLOXAMER 407Emulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
- COCO-GLUCOSIDECleansing Agent, Foaming Agent, Cleansing Surfactant
- PhenoxyethanolAntimicrobial, Preservative
- Butylene GlycolHumectant, Fragrance, Skin Conditioner, Solvent, Viscosity Controller
+13 more ingredients
- Potassium SorbateFragrance, Preservative
- SODIUM LAURETH-12 SULFATECleansing Agent, Foaming Agent, Cleansing Surfactant
- Citric AcidBuffering Agent, Chelating Agent, Fragrance, Exfoliant, Active Ingredient, pH Adjuster
- Sodium BenzoateAnticorrosive, Fragrance, Preservative
- SIMETHICONEAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Hair Conditioner, Skin Conditioner
- AMMONIUM HYDROXIDEBuffering Agent, Denaturant
- IODOPROPYNYL BUTYLCARBAMATEPreservative
- STEARETH-4Emulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
- BHTAntioxidant, Fragrance
- STEARETH-20Cleansing Agent, Emulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
- CI 77492Colorant
- CI 77510Colorant
- CI 77891Colorant
Ingredients Side-by-side
- METHYLPROPANEDIOLSolvent
- STYRENE / ACRYLATES COPOLYMERFilm Former, Opacifying Agent
- STYRENE / ACRYLATES / AMMONIUM METHACRYLATE COPOLYMERFilm Former, Opacifying Agent
- CELLULOSEAbsorbent, Bulking Agent, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller
- PEG-60 HYDROGENATED CASTOR OILEmulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
- COCO-GLUCOSIDECleansing Agent, Foaming Agent, Cleansing Surfactant
- POLOXAMER 407Emulsifying Surfactant, Cleansing Surfactant
- Citric AcidBuffering Agent, Chelating Agent, Fragrance, Exfoliant, Active Ingredient, pH Adjuster
+15 more ingredients
- PhenoxyethanolAntimicrobial, Preservative
- Potassium SorbateFragrance, Preservative
- PHENYLPROPANOLFragrance, Solvent, Perfuming Agent
- Sodium BenzoateAnticorrosive, Fragrance, Preservative
- SODIUM LAURETH-12 SULFATECleansing Agent, Foaming Agent, Cleansing Surfactant
- SODIUM LAURYL SULFATECleansing Agent, Denaturant, Foaming Agent, Cleansing Surfactant
- Caprylyl GlycolDeodorant, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Hair Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Preservative, Humectant
- SODIUM DEHYDROACETATEPreservative
- CI 77007Colorant
- CI 77288Colorant
- CI 77491Colorant
- CI 77492Colorant
- CI 77499Colorant
- CI 77510Colorant
- Ferric Ammonium Ferrocyanide
Ingredients Explained
METHYLPROPANEDIOL
Solvent · Shared
METHYLPROPANEDIOL is a synthetic compound commonly used in cosmetic formulations primarily as a solvent. Its ability to dissolve other ingredients makes it valuable for enhancing the texture and application of products. Formulators may add METHYLPROPANEDIOL to improve the overall feel of a formulation and to help deliver active ingredients more effectively. Additionally, it can contribute to the stability of the product by preventing separation of components, thereby ensuring a uniform consistency throughout the product's shelf life.
COCO-GLUCOSIDE
Cleansing Agent, Foaming Agent, Cleansing Surfactant · Shared
COCO-GLUCOSIDE is a mild surfactant derived from coconut oil and fruit sugars. It is commonly used in cosmetic formulations for its cleansing and foaming properties, making it effective in removing dirt and oils from the skin and hair. Formulators may add COCO-GLUCOSIDE to enhance the overall texture and sensory experience of a product, as it creates a rich lather while being gentle on the skin. Its natural origin and biodegradability also make it a popular choice for those seeking eco-friendly ingredients.
Phenoxyethanol
Antimicrobial, Preservative · Shared
Phenoxyethanol is a widely used cosmetic ingredient recognized for its role as a preservative. It helps to prevent the growth of bacteria, mold, and yeast in cosmetic formulations, thereby extending the shelf life of products and ensuring their safety for consumers. Formulators may add Phenoxyethanol to protect the integrity of the product and maintain its effectiveness over time, especially in water-based formulations where microbial growth is a concern.
Potassium Sorbate
Fragrance, Preservative · Shared
Potassium Sorbate is a widely used preservative in cosmetics and personal care products. It helps to inhibit the growth of mold, yeast, and bacteria, thereby extending the shelf life of formulations. Formulators often add Potassium Sorbate to ensure the stability and safety of their products, particularly those that contain water, as these are more susceptible to microbial contamination. Its effectiveness and relatively low toxicity make it a popular choice in a variety of cosmetic applications.
Citric Acid
Buffering Agent, Chelating Agent, Fragrance, Exfoliant, Active Ingredient, pH Adjuster · Shared
Citric Acid is an organic acid commonly found in citrus fruits and is widely used in cosmetic formulations for its multifunctional properties. As an exfoliant, it helps to remove dead skin cells, promoting a smoother and more radiant complexion. Additionally, it serves as a pH adjuster, ensuring that products maintain an optimal acidity level for skin compatibility. Formulators may add Citric Acid to enhance the overall efficacy of a product and to improve its stability. However, it is important to note that it can be a potential irritant for some individuals, necessitating careful consideration in formulation.