Milani Stay Put 16HR Eyeliner vs Too Faced Killer Liner 36 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner
Both the Too Faced Killer Liner and Milani Stay Put 16HR Eyeliner are formulated to provide long-lasting wear with a waterproof finish, making them suitable for those seeking durability in their eye makeup. The ingredient lists reveal a significant overlap, with both products containing key elements like Dimethicone and TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATE, which contribute to their smooth application and silicone-slip texture. However, the Too Faced option includes additional pigments like CI 77891 and CI 77491, which may affect the color payoff and opacity. While the Too Faced liner is positioned as a premium product, the Milani eyeliner offers a more budget-friendly option without compromising on performance. For those prioritizing value, Milani's offering may be particularly appealing, especially given its similar formulation and shared attributes.
- Match
- 75%
- Price
- $10.99
- Category
- Makeup
- Type
- Eyeliner
- Ingredients
- 10 ingredients
- Match
- 75%
- Price
- $15.60
- Category
- Makeup
- Type
- Eyeliner
- Ingredients
- 14 ingredients
What's inside
What's inside
Key ingredients
No key ingredient signals are available in this snapshot.
Key ingredients
No key ingredient signals are available in this snapshot.
Benefits
No benefit signals are available in this snapshot.
Benefits
No benefit signals are available in this snapshot.
Concerns
No concern signals are available in this snapshot.
Concerns
No concern signals are available in this snapshot.
Ingredients Side-by-side
- DimethiconeAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Skin Protectant, Emollient, Skin Protectant
- CI 77499Colorant
- TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATEAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner
- ACRYLATES / STEARYL ACRYLATE / DIMETHICONE METHACRYLATE COPOLYMERFilm Former
- POLYETHYLENEAbrasive, Film Former, Viscosity Controller
- OZOKERITEBinding Agent, Emulsion Stabilizer, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller
- NYLON-12Bulking Agent, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller
- POLYISOBUTENEBinding Agent, Film Former, Viscosity Controller
Ingredients Side-by-side
- DimethiconeAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Skin Protectant, Emollient, Skin Protectant
- TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATEAntifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner
- POLYETHYLENEAbrasive, Film Former, Viscosity Controller
- SYNTHETIC FLUORPHLOGOPITEBulking Agent, Viscosity Controller
- OZOKERITEBinding Agent, Emulsion Stabilizer, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller
- ACRYLATES / STEARYL ACRYLATE / DIMETHICONE METHACRYLATE COPOLYMERFilm Former
- POLYISOBUTENEBinding Agent, Film Former, Viscosity Controller
- NYLON-12Bulking Agent, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller
Ingredients Explained
Dimethicone
Antifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner, Skin Protectant, Emollient, Skin Protectant · Shared
Dimethicone is a silicone-based polymer commonly used in cosmetics for its emollient properties. It forms a protective barrier on the skin, which helps to lock in moisture and provides a smooth, silky feel. This ingredient is often added to formulations to enhance the texture and spreadability of products, making them easier to apply. Additionally, Dimethicone acts as a skin-protectant, helping to shield the skin from environmental stressors and contributing to a more refined appearance.
CI 77499
Colorant · Shared
CI 77499, also known as Iron Oxide Black, is a colorant commonly used in cosmetics to provide a deep black hue. It is part of the iron oxide family, which includes other colors like red and yellow, and is valued for its stability and opacity. Formulators may add CI 77499 to products to enhance pigmentation, create depth in color formulations, and achieve a desired aesthetic effect in various cosmetic applications. Due to its composition, it is often used in products like foundations, eyeshadows, and other color cosmetics, but it is also subject to regulatory restrictions in certain regions, highlighting the importance of careful formulation practices.
TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATE
Antifoaming, Emollient Skin Conditioner, Skin Conditioner · Shared
TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATE is a silicone-based compound commonly used in cosmetics for its multifunctional properties. It serves primarily as an antifoaming agent, helping to reduce foam formation during the manufacturing process and application of products. Additionally, it acts as a skin-conditioning emollient, providing a smooth and soft feel to the skin, while also enhancing the overall texture of formulations. Formulators may add TRIMETHYLSILOXYSILICATE to improve product performance, stability, and sensory attributes, making it a valuable ingredient in various cosmetic applications.
POLYETHYLENE
Abrasive, Film Former, Viscosity Controller · Shared
POLYETHYLENE is a synthetic polymer commonly used in cosmetic formulations for its versatile properties. It serves multiple functions, including acting as an abrasive in exfoliating products, providing a film-forming effect that can enhance the texture and feel of formulations, and controlling viscosity to ensure the desired consistency of the product. Formulators may add POLYETHYLENE to improve the application experience, enhance product stability, and achieve specific sensory attributes in various cosmetic products.
OZOKERITE
Binding Agent, Emulsion Stabilizer, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller · Shared
OZOKERITE is a naturally occurring mineral wax that is often used in cosmetic formulations for its various functional properties. It serves multiple roles, including binding, emulsion-stabilizing, opacifying, and viscosity-controlling. Formulators may add OZOKERITE to enhance the texture and stability of products, ensuring that ingredients remain well-mixed and that the final product has a desirable consistency and appearance. Its ability to create a smooth application and improve the overall sensory experience makes it a valuable ingredient in many cosmetic formulations.
NYLON-12
Bulking Agent, Opacifying Agent, Viscosity Controller · Shared
NYLON-12 is a synthetic polymer commonly used in cosmetic formulations for its bulking, opacifying, and viscosity-controlling properties. It helps to create a desirable texture and consistency in products, enhancing the overall feel and application. Formulators may add NYLON-12 to improve the product's stability and performance, as it can also contribute to a matte finish and reduce the appearance of shine on the skin.
POLYISOBUTENE
Binding Agent, Film Former, Viscosity Controller · Shared
POLYISOBUTENE is a synthetic polymer commonly used in cosmetic formulations for its versatile properties. It functions primarily as a binding agent, film-former, and viscosity controller, helping to enhance the texture and stability of products. Formulators may add POLYISOBUTENE to improve the adherence of other ingredients, create a smooth application experience, and adjust the thickness of the formulation, making it suitable for various cosmetic products.